Because Oregon and Washington are part of the 9th's jurisdiction it should unless and until it gets overturned by SCOTUS which is not likely. Unlike Immergut's seemingly LSD infused twist on Bruen, Benitez correctly nails it to the wall with ten inch spikes.
My thinking is that because it already made it's way to SCOTUS, who remanded it back down to the 9th, is that it is good law, so it should stand for the entire 9th district!
It also makes it potentially applicable nationwide since SCOTUS briefly kissed it. Perhaps just a matter of time? Also, did you catch the reference to firearm types in Benitez's decision? This has HUGE implications for firearm bans in the 9th Circuit as well.
He directly contradicts himself. He says "if 9th refuses to hear it then we are done in the 9th circuit and this is good law forever".
My understanding is that scotus vacated the previous ruling and said do it over. So now is the post-bruen do-over. What I mean is it's not a scotus stamp of approval for previous or this case. Scotus eliminating previous case and said do it right this time.
The lack of any critical thought by this governor is amazing. There has never been a constitutional convention held. But if one were ever held, we only need to look at constitional carry. 27 states permit it, 23 do not. That makes a majority that is in support of the second. If the topic came up, the majority would be for better protections of the right to be more, not less.
With thinly sliced Bleu cheese on top!
Closest to that was at Hugo's Cellar off Fremont Street in Vegas….
Moldy cheese gets tossed out in this house. We try to consume food before that stage in its life.
More like 4-2 split with 3 wildcards. I permanently include Roberts with the rest of the Deep State's sausagepolishers.
note: that was probably the shortest article about gun rights CNN has ever published and rest assured its not in their headline front and center.
I am sure it had someone there's hair on fire that they were told to even report it.
notice today....I am sure it had someone there's hair on fire that they were told to even report it.
Well of course since something happened in the courts they don't like they HAD to post something like that. It is still CNN after all
oh but so many people tell me CNN is not biased news.Well of course since something happened in the courts they don't like they HAD to post something like that. It is still CNN after all
@Moderators can we merge this with the earlier thread on it (shown below)?
Federal judge overturns California ban on high-capacity gun magazines | CNN
A federal judge struck down California’s ban on firearm magazines holding more than 10 rounds Friday as unconstitutional, “arbitrary and capricious.”amp.cnn.com
www.northwestfirearms.com
Done.@Moderators can we merge this with the earlier thread on it (shown below)?
Duncan v. Bonta Round 2 is OUT!
Just got done watching, YUGE question, William states if the 9th ( Likely) decides NOT to hear this on appeal, then it's GOOD LAW affecting the entire 9th, which includes Oregon and Washington, SO, does this mean Immerguts ruling gets overturned or what? Because Oregon and Washington are part...
