- Messages
- 1,718
- Reactions
- 3,730
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
So on one hand you're saying you don't need sights and on the other you're saying you need target sights.I know a lot of guys like these, and I also recognize that eyes don't get better with age...but something to consider...
At the distances the big dot sights work well, you really don't need sights. In a defensive situation at close range you will do quite well with point shooting. (Try this in a force on force class...you will find that the sights are not used at all)
In cases where there is enough time to and additional accuracy is required, that big front sight covers the target. To hit something, you need a good index on the target. That's hard to do when you can't see it.
Imagine a bad guy not fully behind cover, with just a sliver of flesh available to hit. Or the need to take a shot past a loved one. Or the need to take a longer distance pistol shot. A thin, sharp front sight post is far more conducive to achieving good accuracy.
So on one hand you're saying you don't need sights and on the other you're saying you need target sights.
Cooper would say "front sight", period.. and XS sights are fast and accurate.
Seven yards under real pressure? Most people will do very poorly no matter what they do, to include using (trying to) use their sights.. they will miss.. though they'll try their darndest and really think beforehand that those shots are "gimme's" and that they can just point.No. I'm saying that there are some circumstances where you don't need sights at all, and others where you do.
At close distance, when a bad guy is not under cover, one can point shoot. And that's what most people WILL do under stress at that range.
At distances beyond point shooting range (7yards or so), one must get a more refined sight picture. A sharp front sight post allows much more refined index on the target, whether that's a small target relatively close or a body shot at long distance.
Big dot sights are fast. But there accuracy is limited outside the envelope they were designed for.
Not every problem is the same and we don't know what our fight is going to be. It might be at bad breath distance where it's practically a contact shot. It might be taking a face shot across a crowded room. Or it might be an active shooter at 100 yards.
Big dots were great in a very specific window. But they are an impediment to shooters trying to sharpen and develop their skill outside that window.
Don't take my word for it. Try again aiming for eyeballs at 10 yards. Or a body at 100.
No. I'm saying that there are some circumstances where you don't need sights at all, and others where you do.
At close distance, when a bad guy is not under cover, one can point shoot. And that's what most people WILL do under stress at that range.
At distances beyond point shooting range (7yards or so), one must get a more refined sight picture. A sharp front sight post allows much more refined index on the target, whether that's a small target relatively close or a body shot at long distance.
Big dot sights are fast. But there accuracy is limited outside the envelope they were designed for.
Not every problem is the same and we don't know what our fight is going to be. It might be at bad breath distance where it's practically a contact shot. It might be taking a face shot across a crowded room. Or it might be an active shooter at 100 yards.
Big dots were great in a very specific window. But they are an impediment to shooters trying to sharpen and develop their skill outside that window.
Don't take my word for it. Try again aiming for eyeballs at 10 yards. Or a body at 100.
You're still contradicting yourself, saying that sights at 10 yards are unnecessary yet one needs target sights to hit beyond that and your preposition is flawed saying that XS sights are for a specific problem that you fail to clarify.I've run many Force on Force classes. Where distances are anywhere from contact to 10 yards. In every class, to make a point, I ask students what kind of sight picture they see. Invariably, they admit that they see no sights at all...just the slide superimposed on the opponents body.
They make hits just fine. That's with pressure, moving at full speed, with sims flying back at them.
Point shooting does work, in fact it's very natural. People over complicate things.
Cooper knew what he was talking about but he also wasn't as absolutist as people think. He was practical and realized that different tools work for different circumstances.
Anyway, not saying that the XS sights are a bad product, simply stating they are for a specific problem. If they work for a guy, great. But when he stretches his abilities he will find their limitations.
Jeez, what a boring fool. I doubt very much he's actually used XS sights and or is just a terrible shot.. "What if you have to take a shot beyond 5 yards?!" (referring to XS sights).
Jeez, what a boring fool. I doubt very much he's actually used XS sights and or is just a terrible shot.. "What if you have to take a shot beyond 5 yards?!" (referring to XS sights).
wow
I "like" all sights, pretty much. They all "work".. even to include a simple rudimentary groove in little .25 acp's., if you know what you're doing. You can hit stuff.LOL. There was another video review that I thought was better, I just couldn't find it in my history.
I was looking at sights to replace the standard ones in my Kimber. Wound up selling it and getting a CDP with night sights as a part of the package.
I have had target sights, standard 3-dot sights, 3 dot "combat sights" (wide U, very narrow front blade), and the Steyr trapezoidal. Combat sights are my favorite because it's very easy for me to assess the gap on each side while concentrating on the front blade. The trapezoids are slow to acquire, and I suck, plain and simple, with target sights.
You're still contradicting yourself, saying that sights at 10 yards are unnecessary yet one needs target sights to hit beyond that and your preposition is flawed saying that XS sights are for a specific problem that you fail to clarify.
At the distances the big dot sights work well, you really don't need sights.