Wife and I Fight About Polymer vs. Steel 1911 Glock21

[mr.revolverguy]

Sometimes in marriage there will be ups, downs and disagreements. When you have them it is best to just sit down, talk about it and settle it IMMEDIATELY. Don't let it linger at least that has been a part of the recipe for our longevity. So that's what we did, headed to the range to try and settle this once and for all.

What's Your Preference?

Read More

 

[Nosferatu]

I like 1911's for their history, accuracy and gorgeous visual design.

I like Glocks for their simplicity, durability and handsome functional design.

I will never play the this-or-that. They both have their purpose and are equally bubblegum or shine depending on your personal perspective.

 

[mr.revolverguy]

You don't have to bite or make a decision I fully understand that logic. BUT cmon really Glock HANDSOME???????????????????

 

[Member 34319]

At least you both agree on the boomer cartridge!

 

[FourTeeFive]

My vote is a Sig P220; alloy frame. I've got a 1911 which shoots great but I'm not into the cocked and locked carry. And I've got a Glock 21SF but I don't enjoy shooting it as much as the P220 or 1911.

 

[Andy54Hawken]

My vote would got to the 1911.
However....
If your or anyone else's vote went to the Glock...then that would be okay.

After all...it would be a boring gun world if we all liked and used the same thing.
Andy

 

[Ura-Ki]

I gotta go with the 1911, the CLASSIC all others try to follow!
That said, the utility and simplicity of the Glonk, SIG, and others is just fine if they can run reliable every time!

 

[Yarome]

You're married to her and didn't agree she was right... no matter her opinion? I wouldn't start shopping for your golden anniversary just yet, buddy.

Just sayin....

 

[Member 53328]

Depends on the application/intended use… is it a carry weapon? A home defense weapon? A range toy? Etc.

 

[Whisky Tahoe]

Since I bought most of my guns last century, my experiences probably don't translate well. Lately I have been tuning & upgrading what I have.

Kimber Gold Match 1911 was my first choice. I love the grip angle, accuracy, and history. I've heard not all 1911s are accurate but have potential.
HK USP Tactical Elite was my next purchase. Capacity and accuracy along with a case that had pouch for the suppressor. It's a big gun.
Last, I bought my Gen2 G21 to wear out at the range and it was my first real carry pistol

Recently I've upgraded my G21 with a threaded barrel and enjoy shooting both the Glock and the HK suppressed.

Glocks have functionality and similarity going for them. Learn one, the rest are similar. There is value to that (for some)
I'm shooting more 10mm now than 45acp with a G20 and a G29

When practice time is limited you practice with what you carry. That is probably why I don't shoot the 1911 as much.

Nothing beats practice both live fire as well as dry fire & off hand training. Teaching your "other" hand new tricks keeps your brain sharp.

 

[Nosferatu]

You don't have to bite or make a decision I fully understand that logic. BUT cmon really Glock HANDSOME???????????????????

Certainly.

handsome
adjective

1. Pleasing in form or appearance, especially having strong or distinguished features.

I appreciate functional design.

Men are Jeeps. Women are Ferraris.

 

[Yarome]

Men are Jeeps. Women are Ferraris.

That doesn't hold water when when a man is a dump truck and a woman is a vanogan.

 

[Nosferatu]

That doesn't hold water when when a man is a dump truck and a woman is a vanogan.

Dump trucks aren't great at holding water either!

 

[FourTeeFive]

Dump trucks aren't great at holding water either!

And the older they get, the more they leak…

 

[solv3nt]

And the older they get, the more they leak…

Sounds like your typical man to me...

 

[mr.revolverguy]

Certainly.

handsome
adjective

1. Pleasing in form or appearance, especially having strong or distinguished features.

I appreciate functional design.

Men are Jeeps. Women are Ferraris.

I still say cmon handsome --Pleasing in the eye of the beholder to me functional yes excellent reliability BUT