Opening a can of worms, 9mm question

[spookshack]

It looks like EAA has a new DS 1911. The Girsan 2311. A poor man's Prodigy? MSRP is $999. Lots of flavors available.

Girsan Witness2311® - EAA Corp. Double Stack

The First Affordable Double Stack 1911 is here with the Girsan Witness2311®. Multiple configurations, slide lengths and calibers. 9mm, 45 ACP, 10mm

eaacorp.com

 

[oremike]

My gut level instinct says a CZ 75 in one form or another might be just right, there are two in the classifieds here but I've yet to get a reply to either of my PM's.

 

[91490]

If at all possible handle and shoot as many as you can. Try to find something that fits you and that you can shoot well. Best advice is to find something that you personally like.

 

[aasbra]

CZ-USA CZ Shadow 2 SA 9mm Pistol, Blk - 91245

Series/Collection: CZ Shadow 2 SA Action: Single Caliber/Gauge: 9mm Luger Capacity: 17 Sight: Fiber Optic Front, Adjustable Rear Slide: Black Steel Safety: Ambidextrous Manual Grip Type: Blue Aluminum Barrel Material: Cold Hammer Forged Frame Material: Steel Frame Finish: Black Barrel Length...

palmettostatearmory.com

 

[The Heretic]

P226

This. A Mk25 version with an additional .40 slide/barrel and a .22 LR conversion kit. If you must, a .357 barrel also. Plenty of aftermarket stuff and mods (even Gucci stuff if you must), 10 to 20 rd mags for 9mm, 10 to 15 rd mags for .40/.357

 

[The Heretic]

My gut level instinct says a CZ 75 in one form or another might be just right, there are two in the classifieds here but I've yet to get a reply to either of my PM's.

those are supposed to be good too

 

[kopcicle]

P226 SAO

SAO in particular. Not a big fan of crunch and tickers.
However, I do own a FEG P9R (Bastard step child of a Browning Hi-Power and a S&W 59) Seems to work fine. Magazines are an issue unless you have some skills.

I also own Browning Hi-power. There is so much written on trigger/mag-disconnect/feed ramp that I don't have to go into it here.

I too spent time on a Beretta 92 FS and compact. Pretty much meh. Worked well but nothing to write home about.

I won't touch a S&W 9mm. Personal preference or abject irrational hatred.

Girsan, Tisas, or take your pick 1911 clone. Get over to https://www.1911forum.com/
Just make sure it runs with your desired defense ammunition without fail.
On a personal and subjective note, don't get suckered into a alloy frame or commander length clone. It just isn't worth the headache.

 

[Member 53328]

I could buy (3) Glocks with 1000 +/- bucks. Haha.

Unfortunately they are plastic and striker fired.

If I were going for something steel framed and hammer fired I'd probably hold out and save the cash until I could triple it and pick up a Triarc Tri-11. Which is probably why I still don't have one. Haha.

 

[Camelfilter]

My gut level instinct says a CZ 75 in one form or another might be just right, there are two in the classifieds here but I've yet to get a reply to either of my PM's.

75B For range, camp, house.

Compact & 2075 RAMI for carry.

They all can accept the 75B magazines, which is pretty convenient. Also all have similar hand fitment, which is fantastic (if they fit).

 

[nammac]

I like the Sig M11-A1 for a non-plastic combat style sidearm. It's 15+1 capacity and has a proven track record. Although it doesn't have adjustable sights, I'm sure that would be easy enough to remedy.

Conceals well too with one of them there Sig custom kydex holsters…

 

[oremike]

Random thoughts, I've got a Glock 22 it's my if I need to get a gun put in an evidence locker let it be the Glock gun. I've had a M-96 Beretta and liked it good enough but I don't have it any more and can't remember why not. I've got a couple Sigs that are good and I've got a CZ rifle that is awesome. I've got 3 1911's so most like those. I'm thinking I haven't had a CZ pistol but those I've fondled felt good in my hand so maybe that's the direction I'll go. Of course for the right deal who knows.

Edited to add this would be a pop can and paper plate range toy. Maybe some speed steel and dueling tree when I've got the time.

 

[TTSX]

I could buy (3) Glocks with 1000 +/- bucks. Haha.

That's funny. When I'm buying guns I also quantify them via how many Glocks they cost. Seems like a good standard of comparison to me

 

[unionguy]

Langdon Tactical Beretta 92. Ask @Joe13, I'm a total snob. The double action and single action were on par with my 90s Python. My daily carry is a Wilson Combat CQB Compact in Turnbull blue, and all of my ARs rock Geissele triggers. The stock Beretta is junk without the trigger job. I've read that the Langdon trigger job in a bag is good, but I've only had the Langdon trigger job so I can't comment on that.

The Mecgar mags are 18 rounds standard.

@Nosferatu will agree with me.

Swapping out the hammer spring for a "D" spring or better yet one of LTT's chrome silicon vastly improves the trigger for almost no money. Getting LTT to do the whole thing is of course a whole 'nother level and they are divine!

 

[Jay Walk]

Out of the firearms you mentioned, Beretta, is the clear standout.
They are a five-hundred-year-old family-owned business for a reason.

I purchased a m9 in 22 on a whim and cannot believe the quality of that gun.

 

[Member 53328]

That's funny. When I'm buying guns I also quantify them via how many Glocks they cost. Seems like a good standard of comparison to me

I also gauge all my purchases by how many Glocks I could buy. And if I would rather have the Glocks that's the direction I go. Haha. Probably why I have a few of them.

 

[Pete F]

CZ's are great, but I went with EAA/Tanfoglio. They were imported first and have more of a selection for CZ type guns. They are also slightly cheaper in price without loss of quality. I have owned five. The latest is the EAA Steel Compact.

 

[ma96782]

Your list of desirable traits sounded like you wanted a "Target Shooting/Range handgun" (which could also be a full sized holster carry/duty sized firearm).

IMHO....all of the below choices, will do.
Sig 226/228/229
CZ-75
Browning Hi-Power (and clones)
S & W 5906
There might be more but.....moving on.......

So then, there are some differences/peculiarities about the operations of each. But, you just need to get use to them and of course practice.

Come back again when you narrow it down. I'm sure there will be a lot MORE opinions offered (if you'd want to hear them).

Meanwhile, to me there are also the other considerations. Like.....
Weight, if you're gonna carry it around.
The holster style (safety/retention).
What will fit your drawing style?

BUT, But, but.....what IF.....I actually wanted to CCW it?

Although you could (with the above choices)......me, I'd pick a different handgun at that point. That being said....the M1911 and P225 is not what I have in mind for me.

Anyway.....yeah it's your choice as to what you want and what you envision for your new 9mm. Hell....it's like you're asking the forum to help pick your life partner. BTW, I prefer a brunette (w/o the gray).



Note that.....
In my day (gun buying days) I could buy and sell almost at will or depending on which way the wind was blowing. Buying and selling, was just a part of my life style. Sadly.....now a days.....it appears more and more, that the Govt wants to be involved with every step and purchase decision.

Aloha, Mark

 

[Benchrest]

I own a lot of 9mm pistols, none of them terribly fancy or expensive, but a numerous bunch. Of all I own, and shot, the Walther PDP is where I've landed. I did upgrade the trigger (Overwatch) and added some Taylor Freelance bits, but out of the box it's fantastic. With a RD is the fastest gun I've shot, and I'm the definition of un-fast

If you can get past the plastic bits I think you should handle one.

 

[monkeybutler]

CZs wish they were hi-powers.

 

[DangerDog]

Beretta 92 all day long! Probably the only 9mm I'd ever own.