If you could have any 1 handgun in each caliber...

[SLO]

...what would it be?

I'll start it off with a few popular calibers:

.22LR - Ruger SR22
.380ACP - Walther PPK
.38 - S&W J-frame
9mm - Beretta 92A1 or Glock 19 (9mm is the hardest one for me to decide)
.40S&W - HK USP (Tactical)
.45ACP - 1911

Sig 226 should be on the list too. 9mm is the only one I would have a hard time choosing just 1 gun.

Read More

 

[civilian75]

My list
.22LR - Browning Buckmark
.38SPC - S&W J-frame
.357Mag - S&W686-Plus
9mm - S&W Shield
.40S&W - Sig P229
.45ACP - 1911


By the way, I don't think there are any J-frames chambered in .380ACP

 

[SLO]

By the way, I don't think there are any J-frames chambered in .380ACP

My bad, meant .38

 

[Mark W.]

Is this as in ONLY ONE or one in addition to what I have now?

Cause the first part ain't happening.

 

[SLO]

Just one if you had to start from scratch...

 

[GFO]

.22lr-Ruger Single Six 22lr/22mag
.32 auto-Walther PPK
.380- Sig P238
.38spl-S&W J
.357mag- Ruger GP100
9mm-G19
.40S&W-HK P2000
.41 Rem Mag-Ruger Blackhawk
.44 Rem Mag-Colt Python
.45acp-Colt 1911

Sorry, I added some calibers

 

[oli700]

22 Ruger mkII
9x18 CZ 82
357/38 Ruger Blackhawk
9x19 CZ 75 SP-01
10mm auto G29(my edc)
454 Casull Ruger Alaskan

 

[G1GRANDEUR]

Though choice.

.22 = s&w 617
.380 = never looked into it
.38 = never looked into it
9mm = CZ 75 Shadow SA
.40S&W = never looked into it
.45 = ed brown special forces

 

[Asp]

.22LR - Ruger MARK III
.380 9x18mm - EG or Russian, Makarov (Big, heavy, and a breeder dog to clean)
.38spc - Ruger Blackhawk
.357 - Ruger GP100
9mm - Glock 19
10mm - Glock 20
.40 - Glock 20 (USP or M&P)
.45 - USP (Reg or Tac)
.45LC - Vaquero or Blackhawk
.44 mag - Ruger Redhawk
7.62x25 - 1911

 

[Pandaz3]

.22 LR Colt Diamondback
.22 Mag Ruger Single Nine
.380 PPK or Colt Mustang or maybe the new Ruger LC380
.38 Spl Colt Diamondback
.327 Freedom Arms Model 97
.357 Magnum Colt Cobra
.357 Sig Sig 220
9 MM Springfield XPm 3.8
10 MM STI "Perfect Ten"
.40 Springfield EMP
.44 Special Ruger Blackhawk
.44 Mag Ruger Super Blackhawk
.45 ACP Les Baer "Boss"
.45 LC Colt Single Action Army
.454 Casull Freedom Arms Model 83

 

[SLO]

Interesting list so far. More vast than I anticipated. And more Glocks than I anticipated!

I forgot one in the 9mm category, which would probably trump the 92 and Glock 19...Sig P226

 

[MarkAd]

I hate to be a spoiler, but if you have a 38SPL, then you can not have a 357 because that would give you 2 pistols in 38SPL. Nor could you have a 44 mag and a 44 spl. for the same reason.
BUT thanks for playing

 

[kukusya]

S&W M&P 9mm with 5inch barrel and Extreme Shock "Fang Face"

 

[SynapticSilence]

.22 LR: Ruger 22/45
.22 WMR: Ruger LCR (just out)
.380: Beretta 84FS
9mm: CZ-75B Omega
.357 Magnum: Ruger SP101 (small)
.357 Magnum: S&W 686 (large)
.38 Special: S&W 442 Airweight (+P)
.40: Kahr PM40 or CM40
.45 LC: Ruger New Model Blackhawk
.45 ACP: Sig Sauer C3 1911

 

[gehrheart]

.22lr Colt woodsman
.25 acp colt jr vest pocket
.380 acp Colt mustang
9mm sig 220
.357 colt python
10mm (dont really want a .40) Colt delta 1911
.44 colt anaconda
.50ae desert eagle
.45acp colt 1911 (or a good springer) even though I carry an XD my hart will always be with the 1911
.45lc ruger new model blakhawk
.460 smithwesson xvr

 

[ARWright]

.22lr - Walther P22
.22 mag - Taurus model 94 (4 in. blued/back when they cared.)
.25 acp - Raven P-25
.32 acp - Walther PPK
.380 acp - Colt Mustang
9mm - Glock 17
.38 sp. - Smith & Wesson 12 airweight (snub)
.357 - Smith & Wesson 686+ (6 in. Full Lug)
.40 - Sig Sauer p229
.44 Mag - Smith & Wesson 629 "The Classic" (5 in. Full lug)
.45 acp - Sig Sauer p220 / Sig Sauer 1911
.45 lc - Smith & Wesson The Governor (2 in.)

 

[GOG]

.22 Ruger Single Six
.380ACP Colt 1907
9x18mak CZ82
9mm Browning Hi Power
.38/.357mag Ruger Security Six
Nothing in .40 S&W- don't care for the round
10mm Colt Delta Elite
.45ACP Colt Lightweight Commander
.44spl/mag 6.5" S&W 629

 

[Sun195]

45acp = German Luger

Ka-ching$$$ if it's an original one.

 

[Sun195]

.22LR S&W 617 4"
.22WMR Ruger Single-Six 4"
.25ACP Walther TPH
.32ACP L.W. Seecamp
.380 Beretta 84FS
.38SPL S&W Model 10 4"
.357 Magnum S&W 686 4"
9mm Glock 19
.40S&W Glock 23
10mm Glock 20SF
.45ACP Colt 1911 5"
.41 Magnum Ruger Blackhawk 6"
.44 Magnum S&W 629 5"

 

[Sirmohawk]

I wish I had a Colt Anaconda Nickel or SS .44 Magnum and a top shelf 1911 45 ACP like Kimber.