PA court? decides selling firearms isn't a constitutional right...

[bentoncity]

Just when I thought the courts couldn't get any dummer, along comes this crap...I stated 'courts' but re-reading the article decided the word is a misnomer.

Dan

PA Commonwealth Court Holds That The Commercial Sale Of Arms Is NOT Protected By The Second Amendment

Today, in what appears to be another political, non-judicial, decision issued by the Pennsylvania Courts in the recent week, the Commonwealth Court, en banc, in a decision written by Judge Lori Dum…

blog.princelaw.com

Read More

 

[VinnieBoomBah]

"we decline to extend Bruen to an implied right to engage in the commercial sale of arms because it is too attenuated from the right of law-abiding individuals to keep and bear arms for self-defense."

So as I read that, so long GCA '68!!!

Ok, so not what they are thinking, but if there is no right to commercial sales, how can there be restrictions on them?

 

[Nosferatu]

Excellent! All guns must be free.

 

[CamoDeafie]

"we decline to extend Bruen to an implied right to engage in the commercial sale of arms because it is too attenuated from the right of law-abiding individuals to keep and bear arms for self-defense."

So as I read that, so long GCA '68!!!

Ok, so not what they are thinking, but if there is no right to commercial sales, how can there be restrictions on them?

Well. Maybe free press &freedom of speech only means no implied right to commercial press and speech broadcast by sponsors or corporations, ergo ads are not protected by 1A?

Excellent! All guns must be free.

I suppose private f2f sales without bg checks are "fully constitutional"?

 

[Stomper]

"we decline to extend Bruen to an implied right to engage in the commercial sale of arms because it is too attenuated from the right of law-abiding individuals to keep and bear arms for self-defense."

So as I read that, so long GCA '68!!!

Ok, so not what they are thinking, but if there is no right to commercial sales, how can there be restrictions on them?

Sounds like "judge" Lori Dum(b)as(s) needs a basic civics lesson on ANCILLARY RIGHTS!





But then again, they know FULL WELL the games they're playing.

 

[ZA_Survivalist]

Pretty hard to keep and bear arms if the government withholds access to said arms.

 

[VinnieBoomBah]

It such a garbage ruling that I almost think the judge j

Sounds like "judge" Lori Dum(b)as(s) needs a basic civics lesson on ANCILLARY RIGHTS!





But then again, they know FULL WELL the games they're playing.

Or the judge looked at it and decided a world class game of Hot Potato was in order and just punted it as far away as possible. I can't see any way that stands up on appeal

 

[Certaindeaf]

But selling your soul to beelzebub is, apparently. You go, witch!

 

[Stomper]

It such a garbage ruling that I almost think the judge j

Or the judge looked at it and decided a world class game of Hot Potato was in order and just punted it as far away as possible. I can't see any way that stands up on appeal

The 4th circuit says…. hold my beer, watch this!