RifleClass.com
Low Price Guns
J&B Firearm Sales
Advertise on Northwest Firearms
Buster Beaver Cerakote
Defensive Arts
Gun Deals
Oregon Rifleworks
Oregon Arms & Ammunition
Sporting Systems
Southwest Firearms Forum
Welcome to Northwest Firearms
Join our community, sign up for free today!
Sign Up

EDC Ruger revolver

DeanMk

Messages
2,557
Reactions
3,072
GP100 (1705) or Redhawk (5050).

Differences are 4 oz. weight and $250 (MSRP).
Carried in outside belt holster.
Redhawk will only be loaded with .45 Colt ammo (not ACP).

Which would you choose for your EDC and why?
 
Last edited:

orygun

Messages
5,785
Reactions
6,731
OP
DeanMk

DeanMk

Messages
2,557
Reactions
3,072
EDIT!...and an apology...

I should've stated that the Redhawk would only be loaded with .45 COLT ammo....not too interested in the ACP round.
Sorry for any confusion that omittance may have caused.
I have now corrected my opening statement.
 

orygun

Messages
5,785
Reactions
6,731
EDIT!...and an apology...

I should've stated that the Redhawk would only be loaded with .45 COLT ammo....not too interested in the ACP round.
Sorry for any confusion that omittance may have caused.
I have now corrected my opening statement.
After digging a little deeper into the Ruger catalog, I see that even though it's listed as a 45 ACP chamber, it uses moon clips for the ACP, but will chamber the 45 Colt. That makes a lot more sense to me. Load that sucker up! My only complaint against the 45 Colt is availability of good ammo compared to the 44 Mag. If you're a handloader, that point is moot. If I was going to buy a Redhawk, though, it would be in 41 Mag! (My fav)

Still, my personal choice is for a slightly smaller, lighter gun.
Too bad Ruger won't make the GP100 in a 5 shot 44 Mag.

(Says the guy with a S&W Mod 69 who wishes it was available in 41 Mag.)
 
Messages
782
Reactions
1,092
I was interested in a gp100 in 44 spcl but I kept reading issues with cylinder walls being too thin and wasn't as accurate. I think the gp100 is just not strong enough to handle 44 cal in spcl or magnum.
 

DLS

Messages
1,163
Reactions
1,753
GP100s are one of the more solid revolvers out there. I've not heard of any durability issues with the larger rounds such as 10mm or .44 Special.

Where are the reports otherwise coming from? Looking to learn here.
 
Messages
15,173
Reactions
30,135
GP100s are one of the more solid revolvers out there. I've not heard of any durability issues with the larger rounds such as 10mm or .44 Special.

Where are the reports otherwise coming from? Looking to learn here.
Yeabut if you load it up to casull levels it'd probably bend. lol
 
Messages
6,596
Reactions
25,080
GP100 (1705) or Redhawk (5050).

Differences are 4 oz. weight and $250 (MSRP).
Carried in outside belt holster.
Redhawk will only be loaded with .45 Colt ammo (not interested in ACP).

Which would you choose for your EDC and why?
Are you stopping men or stopping things that see you as dinner?
 

Jonnyuma

Messages
1,703
Reactions
4,285
Unless you hand load, I'd steer towards the .357 GP100 just for simplicity and cost.

When I had my .454 Super Redhawk (7-8 yrs ago) I had a hard time finding decent loads in 45 or 454 and when I did they were about a buck/rd.... not for plinking.
:s0161:

Same with my .44 SBH and (at least at the time), .44Spl cost more than magnums.
:s0161:

My old .41mag Redhawk suffered much the same fate... safe queen, then sold.
:s0161:

Either gun will serve, but you gotta figure in the cost of feeding it. Depending on how much you shoot, that is a factor.

BTW... I regret selling all three of those guns but with a family and bills I had to do what I had to do. I might make a different decision now.

Speaking of regrets (last thing, I promise), in the 90s I kept my 4" GP100 and sold a similar Colt King Cobra. A dumb move on my part, but who knew the Colt snake guns were going to appreciate like they did. I was satisfied w that decision until I saw what the Colts were fetching at auctions years later. Oops.
 

NEW CLASSIFIED ADS

LATEST REVIEWS

  • Rapid Fire Arms
    5.00 star(s)
    Great place friendly service always take time to help you, great knowledge of products
    • RJSouth
  • Supporting Vendor Copeland Custom Gunworks
    5.00 star(s)
    Perfect install of peep sight on my cz 527 carbine. Price was right, was expecting it to be more. Will be my go to for anything I can't handle...
    • cd90caprice
  • Adaptive Firing Solutions
    5.00 star(s)
    I've been party to a couple transactions with Steve and he is a great guy to deal with.
    • titsonritz
  • TJ Gun Sales
    5.00 star(s)
    Purchased two handguns there and have one on consignment now nice folks!
    • rl280
  • Northwest Armory - Tigard
    5.00 star(s)
    Went in to help my buddy with his purchase and ended up trading in a 1911 towards a CZ SP-01 Tactical. They gave a higher price that some of the...
    • nosbocaj

SUPPORT NORTHWEST FIREARMS

Staff online