Welcome to Northwest Firearms
Join our community, sign up for free today!
Sign Up

Best 44 mag ammo for deer?

Messages
45
Reactions
104
I've been thinking the Hornady leverevolution, or maybe some extreme penetrators..I want good knock down power but good penetration as well...hunting with a henry big boy

220gr-44-magnum-xtreme-penetrator-ammo-lehigh-defense-sku-07421220S-500x500.jpg
amm-4992_1.jpg
 
Last edited by a moderator:
OP
M
Messages
45
Reactions
104
I've been thinking the Hornady lever evaluation, or maybe some extreme penetrators..I want good knock down power but good penet ration as well...hunting with a henry big boy
 
Messages
908
Reactions
565
300 gr XTP is one of the best bullets I have used in the .44 Mag for deer.
If you hand load there are many good bullets to use both jacketed and cast.
 
Messages
1,720
Reactions
2,179
I would think just about any bullet out of a 44 mag rifle would quickly and easily dispatch a deer.

That being said, I would pick a good hard cast bullet with a gas check, or any of the soft point 240 grain bullets available.
I would probably stay away from the hollow points as they will have less penetration than the cast or soft point designs.
 

orygun

Messages
5,618
Reactions
6,389
HSM has a hunting ammo that's a good Sierra 240gr bullet at slightly below normal 240gr velocity, but it is easy to control in a revolver. The carbine will boost velocities compared to a pistol and unless you're trying to stretch ranges it will work well.
The Hornady XTP is one tough bullet and can handle high velocities. I loaded them up in a 41 Mag (210gr) and shot them at over 1800fps. They wouldn't come apart. If it was me, I'd load Hornady XTP's and push them as fast as you can and still get decent groups. I think it's the best, toughest handgun bullet out there. it was very accurate in my Ruger Blackhawk and Marlin 1894.
 

Spitpatch

Messages
1,954
Reactions
1,157
No experience here with .44 magnum on deer. On the other hand, a moderate number of kills with .357's and .41's. The XTP is the best thing since sliced bread for this work (and in years past I used other jacketed hollowpoints of years past manufacture). It is VERY accurate in most guns, expands at nearly any reasonable velocity and holds together to penetrate even against bone.

The leaning here towards the heavyweights in my experience is not necessary and neither is the hardcast lead. Those are what I would choose for wilderness defense.

In the .357 a 140gr XTP will penetrate any deer side to side (unless perhaps you smack one or both shoulder bones). It traveled in a Caribou quartering away from the last rib to the skin behind the shoulder on the far side. In the .41 magnum a standard-weight XTP bullet (210gr) will (and did) bust through both shoulders on stout Muleys. Neither caliber in these weights of bullet remained inside Antelope even after smacking a shoulder.

Test for accuracy. Any factory load carrying an XTP will be of sufficient velocity but the load needs to agree with your gun (and revolvers are persnickety). Handloads for hunting should follow the standard goal of balancing velocity and accuracy.
 
Messages
6,930
Reactions
9,820
The XTP is the best thing since sliced bread for this work (and in years past I used other jacketed hollowpoints of years past manufacture). It is VERY accurate in most guns,
Ditto this^. I have been shooting XTPs out of a variety of .357s for years (as well as a Henry) and there is nothing else that compares in a JACKETED bullet.
I have NO experience with the LeverEvolution ammo but I do read reports fairly frequently about poor performance in nearly all calibers it is available in.
Some report fair accuracy but most say its less accurate than they thought it would be.
Personally I am surprised it is still available. Kind of like the old 'Accelerator' .22/.30 cal sabot rounds - another case of a product designed for a problem that did not exist.
 
Messages
6,251
Reactions
19,324
Consider.

The same 240 grain rounds that go 1300 FPS in my 4'' 329 - go 1800+ FPS in my Ruger dearfield.
This could play a part in expansion [Over expansion] .. I don't know. I have yet to shoot a deer with the .44?
 

Spitpatch

Messages
1,954
Reactions
1,157
Yeah. One of my favorite scenes in multiple hunting shows or articles is the "expert" field dressing his game, and upon discovering the projectile (or pieces of such) that does not meet his text-book definition of "performance", begins by saying something to the effect of, "And here we have a classic example of bullet failure..."

The dead deer is politely silent toward this idiocy.
 

NEW CLASSIFIED ADS

LATEST REVIEWS

  • J&B Firearm Sales
    5.00 star(s)
    I've done many transfers with these guys. They know their stuff, they're very approachable and...
    • Art_Vandelay
  • J&B Firearm Sales
    5.00 star(s)
    I've always felt comfortable at J&B, first time I ever went there I walked out with a new Glock...
    • Zapata47
  • Money Market Pawn Shop
    5.00 star(s)
    Maybe I'm biased since I live 5 minutes away, but Peter and his crew have always been friendly...
    • Zapata47
  • Oregon Rifleworks
    5.00 star(s)
    It has been a while since I have been in the store just because I don't get to downtown Tigard...
    • bobcat7677
  • Oregon Rifleworks
    5.00 star(s)
    Love all the Guys and Gals, the redbeard is pleased. Even if it wasn't 1 min away from my house...
    • SVT-ROY

Staff online