Should I refinish a newer Marlin?

[teflon6string]

The Marlin 1894S with the endcap was made in 1983. Despite nicks and scuffs, the wood "furniture" has a deep shiny appearance that really comes alive with just a little oil. It's handsome and easy to maintain, even if it acquires another gouge.

The Marlin 1894C with the strap was made about 2008. The wood on that one has all the lustre and charm of what one pal calls "burl of packing crate." I understand that it will never have the nice natural grain of the older gun, but oiling it does NOTHING for the finish. Is it even wood? Or maybe it's just so coated in something that oil will never touch the actual wood?

I'm contemplating taking it down just far enough to re-stain and oil it for a more natural, old fashioned look and feel. Would that be a mistake? I ask because I tried the same thing with a Fender Telecaster (MIM) and quickly discovered veneer glued over a 3-piece laminated plank. Wrecked the guitar.

So what's my best bet with this newer Marlin? Thanks in advance for helpful tips!

Read More

 

[jbett98]

Try using the orange citrus jell type paint remover by Jasco. it's very easy to use.
Just smear some of it all over, wait five minutes and rub it off with four-ought steel wool.
I prefer using Birchwood Casey "Tru Oil for the finish. It's fairly forgiving to apply, just rub the stock with denatured alcohol after using the citrus oil finish remover.
Sand down the Tru-Oil between coats with the 4/0 steel wool.

 

[mjbskwim]

I would say give it a try and post some pics of the results


Then I will know if I want to try it on my newer lever gun

 

[jonn5335]

Go for it I'd guess it's just a birch stock