Southwest Firearms
Gun Deals
Oregon Rifleworks
Advertise on Northwest Firearms
Low Price Guns
DSG Arms
Sporting Systems
Oregon Arms & Ammunition
Defensive Arts
J&B Firearm Sales
Buster Beaver Cerakote
HighLine Firearms
Simply Triggers

Is the recoil of the .45 ACP excessive?

  • Yes

    Votes: 3 2.1%
  • No

    Votes: 141 97.9%

  • Total voters
    144
  • Poll closed .
Messages
1,056
Reactions
140
I have noticed in several threads the sentiment that the recoil associated the with .45 ACP is "too much". Too much for what? What is the opinion of the group?
 
Messages
586
Reactions
20
I think the recoil is perfect. Granted it can change with your load, and the size/weight of your gun etc., but in all the .45's I've shot, I felt the recoil was just right.
 
It's too much for some people with inadequate wrist/arm strength to keep a decent grasp for a follow up shot. Some do not like the recoil as they are not used to that much or just plain cant handle it.
 
Messages
403
Reactions
63
My 120 pound wife is well into her 60's and doesn't think so. Then again, she shoots full size and Combat Commander weight .45's. She might feel differently about the recoil if she were shooting one of the fly-weight mini-1911's. Me, I can't tell much difference from most 9 mm's. Most of the "recoil" is between the ears.
 
Messages
136
Reactions
5
Not for me, but perceived recoil depends a lot on the the gun design and weight as well as loads used. I personally fell less recoil in a large 45 than a smaller, lighter 40 (neither one is excessive). A persons physical strength and gun handling techniques also effect perceived recoil.
 
Messages
952
Reactions
97
I say no way but it also depends not only on the person shooting but on the pistol itself. A full size 1911 is going to be alot more manageable than say a Kahr PM45.
 
Messages
1,253
Reactions
38
Nah, not in a fullsize, steel frame, recoil operated gun at any rate. I'm faster with 9mm though.

Actually I think the recoil is too much in direct blowback .380s and 9x18s. They are kinda snappy. Seems to me weight and the way guns are operated (blowback vs. recoil or gas) makes the bigger difference.
 
Messages
1,056
Reactions
140
No, but the cost is... :)

You don't need to spend a lot of money to get a great shooting weapon. If you want flash and fancy detailing you can spend a load. But there are a lot of fine shooting and well made weapons out there on the market. I have a mix-master 1911A1 I'd shoot against any high end big name weapon.
 
Messages
108
Reactions
18
My step son has been shooting my 4" aluminum framed Kimber .45 since he was 11 years old. If he can handle it, then anyone can. Proper grip, stance, and mindset are more important than anything else.
Recoil on a .45 is more like a solid push... rather than a sharp snap of a light weight .40.
 
Messages
720
Reactions
77
There's a video online somewhere of a 9/40/45 comparo with time to reaquire sight picture with x amount of shots.
In theory, it was lighter recoil = faster reaquisition of target.

But too much recoil?
I'd have to say no?
 
Messages
1,950
Reactions
3,071
Not a problem - my wife even prefers .45acp over 9mm, .40, and .357 mag.
I've always looked at the .45acp as a "push" recoil vs. more of a snap recoil on even the Glock 17 9mm.
 
Messages
1,056
Reactions
140
There's a video online somewhere of a 9/40/45 comparo with time to reaquire sight picture with x amount of shots.
In theory, it was lighter recoil = faster reaquisition of target.

But too much recoil?
I'd have to say no?

I would guess time to reacquire would be a function of technique and strength, although I have no data to back that up. I can only go by my own experience in timed drills for the DPSST Range qualification.

If I was a smart-***, ( which of course I will deny) I would say while you might need to reacquire and shoot again with a 9mm....you don't with a .45. But I'm not like that....really :D
 
Messages
603
Reactions
12
My 2 cents is that it depends on the length of the barrel and the type of material used to build the frame.

A shooter is going to feel a lot more recoil when shooting a 45 with a 3' barrel made with an aluminum or plastic frame, than they are shooting the same round in a gun with a 5" barrel and a steel frame.

That said, recoil management is the key to getting used too, and learning the gun's recoil habits.

Frog.
 
Messages
1,056
Reactions
140
By that rational this should be all the pistol you need. :D
M1942_liberator.jpg

That pistol was designed to get the person holding it the weapon of the German soldier they just shot. I want one I can reuse!!!!! :)
 
NW Custom Firearms
Cerberus Training Group
DSG Arms
Project Appleseed
Copeland Custom Gunworks
Oregon Arms & Ammunition
Advertise on Northwest Firearms
Sporting Systems
Southwest Firearms Forum

Upcoming Events

22 Rimfire Challenge
Redmond, OR
Rimfire Challenge July 31st @ DRRC
Eagle Creek, OR

Latest Resource Reviews

New Classified Ads

Top