what do you think about a change from a 5" 45 to a 4"?

Kevatc · May 25, 2013

I have a Springfield XD 45 tactical (5") that I've put a nice 3.5# trigger and some TFO night sights on. I can shoot it pretty well even at 25 yards and with some gauging shots I can hit a milk jug at 100 yards. My only problem is its a large pistol which makes it harder to conceal but even harder to find a good holster for it.

Would I be nuts for trading it for a 45 acp service model?

Miravox · May 25, 2013

http://www.ballisticsbytheinch.com/45auto.html

PuddleMonkey · May 25, 2013

it might not be in the cards for you, but why not just get a inexpensive pocket pistol or compact carry gun and keep your Tactical?

MarkAd · May 25, 2013

get a 3 inch compact 45, great carry gun.

Jammer Six · May 27, 2013

I went the other direction.

1911s smaller than a government model are not as reliable as a full sized weapon, and a full sized weapon is just as easy to carry as a 3 inch model. The magic isn't in the length, it's in the width, and that is the same.

Good luck!

RVTECH · May 28, 2013

but even harder to find a good holster for it.

I have owned both Commander and full size - and after finding the perfect holster (for me anyway) the Bianchi 77L - it's full size all the way. This holster carries my 1911 comfortably and conceals well.

dallen1x · May 31, 2013

I had a 5" 1911 but now have a 3" version for several reasons.
Probably the biggest issue for me was driving.
I like how a high-ride holster keeps the pistol from binding when I'm in the car.
I also like how the shorter barrel does not project lower than my jacket.
If the 3" was not available for purchase then I would go with the commander size.