Simple Question Which One?

[NU9MM]

Your two choices are Sig P365 XMacro or Glock 19. And why please. I know there's many many other choices out there, but those are your only two choices.

Read More

 

[1775usmc]

Glock 19. Simply cause I hate Sig as a company. Although I have owned a X macro for a period of time. The mags and slide would show surface rust daily as an EDC. But it was a fun gun to shoot. They are both quality products but you can't beat the reputation of a Glock.

 

[Nosferatu]

For what?

 

[oremike]

Sig, because Sig. And I'll spend all of YOUR money I can.

 

[TTSX]

When there is a choice between a Glock 19 and anything else when no context of why is given, I'm going with the Glock every single time. If you can refine your question to how it will be used, my answer might change.

 

[orygun]

If those are my only two choices, it doesn't matter. Neither is on any list that I would consider purchasing.

 

[orygun]

For what?

Selling?

 

[nammac]

Assuming this is for concealed carry…

P365 and G19 are both fine firearms. Both plenty accurate. Both plenty reliable. For me personally, I'll take an original P365 micro, 12 round mags with +2 MagGuts upgrade to bring that to 14+1 onboard in a slightly smaller, slightly lighter package for EDC.

Just my opinion and worth all that was paid for it.

 

[TTSX]

Assuming this is for concealed carry…

P365 and G19 are both fine firearms. Both plenty accurate. For me personally, I'll take an original P365 micro, 12 round mags with +2 MagGuts upgrade to bring that to 14+1 onboard in a slightly smaller, slightly lighter package for EDC.

Just my opinion and worth all that was paid for it.

I want a refund

 

[NU9MM]

For what?

EDC

 

[NU9MM]

When there is a choice between a Glock 19 and anything else when no context of why is given, I'm going with the Glock every single time. If you can refine your question to how it will be used, my answer might change.

EDC

 

[NU9MM]

I've had both. It's just a curious question. But it would be for EDC. I also have the M&P 2.0 3.6" optic ready 9mm.

 

[orygun]

I've had both. It's just a curious question. But it would be for EDC. I also have the M&P 2.0 3.6" optic ready 9mm.

I'd take the Smith over either.

 

[nammac]

Said P365 with MagGuts + 2 in place…. Adds literally nothing to the arms dimensions…

 

[Nosferatu]

Sig is smaller, if that matters to you.

I have a P365 and have had 4 G19's at a few points in my life. I mainly carry a S&W M&P 10mm since I don't live in a vacuum and other guns do actually exist.

 

[1775usmc]

Carry what you shoot best and will actually carry. All three are reliable and tested. Some have more time in the system and better reputation and they all come with some personal bias and a fan base.

 

[spookshack]

They both have their pros and cons and without more context from the OP, I'll give my top 3 pros for choosing Sig.

1. Modular chassis and the ability to run a manual safety.
2. Thinner in slide and grip (more comfortable).
3. Direct mounting of my preferred red dot optic (Holosun EPS).

 

[1911Fanatic]

I'd take the Glock, as long as it's one with the changeable back straps. Mags are cheap. Less than half of what Sig mags go for. Greater aftermarket possibilities. They eat everything you feed them, parts such as springs are usually cheaper. There are so many reasons.

 

[NU9MM]

I'd take the Glock, as long as it's one with the changeable back straps. Mags are cheap. Less than half of what Sig mags go for. Greater aftermarket possibilities. They eat everything you feed them, parts such as springs are usually cheaper. There are so many reasons.

I found a Gen4 for $399. Can't decide on that or the Gen5. Yeah the XMacro mags are $60

 

[1911Fanatic]

I found a Gen4 for $399. Can't decide on that or the Gen5

I have a 19X. It's an older one without the optics cut. I'm not sure which gen it is. I don't know how one tells anymore these days.