Poll: Do you like revolvers in automatic cartridges?

[GuyM]

Both of those guns are wearing "neck feather" grips, which were '67 only, which is why I asked.

See? You know more about my Rugers than I do! I believe that those are the original grips. The brass grip frames seem to be factory as well, from what little I know about the brass grip frames.

Regards, Guy

 

[OrPackrat]

Sold a few of them, neat function allowing for cheaper practice. I've never found the need to own one.

Perhaps if I decided I need a 357 at some point. But for now, 10mm does the job...

 

[Greg S]

The one that keeps coming to mind for me is the classic 4" 625 and the GP100 IN 10mm.

I think the GP being a beefy mid frame is strong enough although there were some growing pains in 44 Spec with forcing cone cracks.

The S&W pretty much has the 45 ACP seen up but I think Ruger has the better mousetrap with the 10mm GP.

Eh, it's only $ and not need to panic buy as it is a wheelie!

 

[CountryGent]

@Greg S I've really enjoyed the various flavors of 25 (25—2, 625—2, 325PD) in the line up. The moon-clip format has grown on me; they're just handy. With the target guns, I'll often plop a few in left pocket of sports coat, shoot up target, and drop empties in right. Easy-peasy, reusable, and inexpensive compared to magazines for automatics. (And, yes, I am being an enabler. But that is to be expected at this point. )

 

[kmk1012]

Here's my second favorite revolver in pistol cartridge that I own. A rare S&W 646 Perf Center (40S&W), one of 163 made. Still have everything it came with including locking metal box. I'm in CA now and wanted to be compliant, so it's my CA hi cap gun, LOL. Just don't tell anyone that those boolits contain PB, I'll have to tell them it goes well with the jelly. Also, here's my fuel efficient commuter car we took, actually needed the room and power for the trip down here. Getting out of CA and headed for NV in the morning. Will be a nice drive, my 15yo son will be behind the wheel. First time not driving on a road trip in 30+ years.

 

[ilikegunspdx]

They are no for me. I don't like that huge gap between the cylinder and frame on ones I've seen. Looks like they just wanted to save $ instead of designing it properly. Maybe others exist that doesn't have that huge gap I don't know.

 

[kmk1012]

Post #85 looks like any other revolver, that is in 40 S&W. I had the exact same thoughts you did about the cylinder in my other S&W in 9mm (929). That was until I started shooting it. Most of these are for competition and shaving weight a little here and there helps out. Most competition shooters shoot high volume and need to reload quickly, hence the reason for pistol cartridge chamberings. I'm no competition shooter at all but enjoy shooting revolvers far more than semi auto pistols, better triggers, no chasing brass, etc. the cost savings vs revolver cartridges can really add up as well.

 

[orygun]

The one that keeps coming to mind for me is the classic 4" 625 and the GP100 IN 10mm.

I think the GP being a beefy mid frame is strong enough although there were some growing pains in 44 Spec with forcing cone cracks.

The S&W pretty much has the 45 ACP seen up but I think Ruger has the better mousetrap with the 10mm GP.

Eh, it's only $ and not need to panic buy as it is a wheelie!

This is where I think Ruger is missing the boat. A GP100 in 41 Mag, even if it was only a 5 shot would be a great gun.

 

[Mark W.]

Does a Ruger Blackhawk in .30 carbine count? The .30 carbine is certainly an autoloader round and the Blackhawk is sure a revolver.

In which case its very accurate a great gun to shoot and louder then pretty much anything I have ever shot.

 

[CountryGent]

@Mark W. sounds super neato. I've looked on and of for a revolver in .30 Carbine as a companion to a couple carbines we have so chambered.

 

[Greg S]

GP 100 in 41 Mag would be sweet!

S&W is coming out.with a 10mm Mountain Gun. The 45 Colt versions are going between 12 and 1600 which is a non start when you can get an Anaconda for 14.

 

[Aught Six]

The autos are limited to space. revolvers are not.
It is dumb to GIMP a firearm uses weenie ammo to fit in an auto.

No a 9mm is NOT as good as a 357 mag. Never has been, never will be.
Yet only 1/1000th difference between the two.

 

[Andy54Hawken]

Not arguing here...

Just tossing this out as something to consider.....

If...
A threat is stopped with a .357 Magnum...
Is the threat "more stopped"...than if the same threat was stopped with a 9mm....?

Again not arguing...or trying to change minds etc.

Just pointing that self defense is very subjective to a person's individual needs and situation.
What may be good for one person with their needs / situation...may be the worst choice for a different person.

Andy

 

[Greg S]

Andy, I don't know your age but 35 years ago you would not be saying that. Projectile science has come a long way since. I recall many a news story were a felon was shot multiple times (double digits) and survived. The only really semi consistent round back then was the Illinois State Police 9mm +P+.

Now days, the 45 ACP 1911 is relaxing more while the G19 goes out.

 

[Andy54Hawken]

Andy, I don't know your age but 35 years ago you would not be saying that. Projectile science has come a long way since. I recall many a news story were a felon was shot multiple times (double digits) and survived. The only really semi consistent round back then was the Illinois State Police 9mm +P+.

Now days, the 45 ACP 1911 is relaxing more while the G19 goes out.

I have said the same thing 35 years ago.

If the threat is stopped...then the threat is stopped.
It don't matter what caliber did the stopping...ain't no such thing as more stopped.

And...
I stand by my statement of self defense being subjective to an individuals needs and situation.
What works well for one person and their situation...may not for someone else.

Andy

 

[Wombat of Doom]

GP100 Snubby in 9mm purchased for CCW in Washington State. I just don't want to deal with Washington and CCW with semi automatics anymore. I usually carry a revolver and for events I do provide some security for, 9mm is an approved caliber.

So currently for when I must travel to Washington, 9mm GP100 it is.

 

[RogueRider]

I wish Smith would bring back some .45 revolvers.

 

[Outpost75]

I have S&W 1950 Military, Colt New Service and S&W 325PD. Also a Ruger Blackhawk Convertible. With good handloads equal to .45 Colt.

 

[CountryGent]

I reckon the answer to my original question would be in the affirmative.


Top to bottom: S&W 25—2 1955 Target Model. Webley Mark Ⅵ. S&W 625—2 1988 Target Model. S&W 325 PD. All specimens in .45 ACP ╱ Auto Rim.

 

[TJ82525]

I prefer automatics for protection but really enjoy shooting revolvers at the range. I find there is something very cathartic about thumbing each round into the chamber of a revolver. I REALLY appreciate this slower pace vs shoving a magazine into a magazine well. I don't like moon clips for revolvers.

I wish my Webley didn't have a shaved cylinder! Some day I will buy some 45acp rimmed brass for it.

View attachment 1937474

My dad left a Webley shaved for 45 Autorim when he passed. Lots of reloads that he made. Haven't actually shot it yet, but planning to one day.