- Messages
- 33
- Reactions
- 20
- Ad Type
- For Sale
- Price
- $1250
- Manufacturer
- Smith & Wesson
- Caliber
- 44 Special
- City
- Springfield
- State
- Oregon
- Zip Code
- 97477
- I agree to the classified rules and terms of service
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
This is correct. As long as no 44mag has been run through it, I would not send it in. If you are not sure, and a 44mag fits, and you want to shoot it, you should be prepared to either lose your gun for a replacement or refund, or demand the frame back and source a replacement cylinder to retrofit. It's not worth the kaboom. This of course applies to you and any prospective buyer With full disclosure.Here's a reply in the article written by Roy Jinks in reply to the guns issues.
"If your gun is within this range and you do not have a box or know for certain that it has been tested, you should contact Smith & Wesson. S&W's records prior to 1986 are not computerized, so it takes them a l little longer to look up the particulars.
"You can E-mail your gun's serial number to:
[email protected]
"S&W will contact you regarding the status of your particular gun. If your gun is included in the recall, you'll be sent a prepaid FedEx label and shipping instructions. While E-mail is best, you may also call S&W Customer Support at 1-800-331-0852.
"Recalled cylinders are tested by magnafluxing*. If your recalled gun does fail, there are no replacement cylinders. S&W will keep your gun and you will be offered the choice of another handgun of equal value or a refund."
The 'real' story from Roy Jinks:
In response to a member's email, asking Roy Jinks about the steel used in the cylinder in February of 2008 and he replied:
"The cylinder problem was the fact that some cylinders had long charge holes and you could chamber the .44 Magnum round in the cylinder. So it is an easy check. If the gun will chamber the .44 Magnum round then it has one of the cylinders that was affected. if it does not chamber the round then you are okay. You will still be okay as long as you shoot only .44 Specials in the revolver.
"Believe what you want to, but it was my project and I certainly do not remember a problem with the stainless steel for the cylinders."
Now think about this:
If S&W were to recall revolvers to have their cylinders checked, wouldn't it be more like factory protocol and make more sense to mark the cylinder rather than stamping a red circled "C" on the box? How many boxes are usually retained with the revolver and how reliable/efficient would a marked box be?
* I suspect magnafluxing was actually to verify if someone had shot 44 Mags in the cylinder and damaged it.
__________________
Jim
S&W CA #819