Poll: Which S&W 1854???

[funbobpdx]

Looking at getting the S&W 1854. No purpose aside from growing my collection for now. I may want to take it hunting at some point. (Deer brush hunting). Which caliber is recommended? One consideration is which caliber is easier to find on shelves as well. Thanks!

Read More

 

[CountryGent]

Never heard of it until now, but seems quite neato. If it were me, wood stock, .44 Magnum.

 

[Tlock]

 

[Tlock]

That one in 44 mag....if they make it

 

[TTSX]

I don't shoot my 44 revolver often enough to justify buying a carbine in the same, nor do I own a .45 Colt in any shape, so I wouldn't choose those chamberings... However I would get the blued version with the wood stock every single time unless I anticipated using it heavily and often in rainy, wet environments. The wood stock just looks great.

 

[mhayd93]

44 magnum, black with stainless! It's a classy yet utilitarian look. I also personally don't like the look of the checkering on wood stock 1854.

 

[titsonritz]

Option #5: None of the above. I'd go for the 44 myah black on black, stealth hunter model.

https://www.smith-wesson.com/product/sw-model-1854-stealth-hunter-44-magnum

But if I was limited to those options only I'd choose stainless and black in 44 mag which is how I voted. BTW it's listed twice but I assumed the only the second one was a typo and meant to be 45.

 

[funbobpdx]

Option #5: None of the above. I'd go for the 44 myah black on black, stealth hunter model.

https://www.smith-wesson.com/product/sw-model-1854-stealth-hunter-44-magnum

But if I was limited to those options only I'd choose stainless and black in 44 mag which is how I voted. BTW it's listed twice but I assumed the only the second one was a typo and meant to be 45.

Yes, typo, thanks for the feedback!