RCBS 10-10 scale zeroing difficulties.

Messages
292
Reactions
28
First of all, you won't offend me if you tell me i'm an idiot and am doing something wrong. I want to learn. I finally got everything I need to reload and started my first rounds this weekend. I'm using a RCBS 10-10 beam scale and am running into some problems. I zeroed the scale and loaded 25 rounds. These are my test/work-up loads so I measured everyone of them. Today I started loading the next small batch with another powder and decided to make sure my zero was still good. When I re-zeroed it, it was off by around 0.7 grains. So, after each batch of 5 rounds I rechecked the zero and found that it changes on me. I checked and double checked to make sure everything was in order and i'm not sure what is going on. Any ideas would be appreciated.
 
Messages
116
Reactions
5
I gave up on the beam style as well, but I re-zero my digital rcbs about every couple weeks, and will always check it at the beginning of each session with a 100g and 20g check weight. If it is off by more then .2 grains it gets reset.
 
Messages
2,405
Reactions
555
Make sure that the surface you are working on is smooth and preferably as level as possible. The Beam Scales rely on "Level" for zeroing. The beam remains level when their is no weight on it but if the base of the scale changes position, the indicator line moves. I had this problem and finally found a piece of melamine coated particle board from an old cabinet. Used it for a scale work surface. Screwed it to my bench and shimmed it level. Scale stopped giving me fits.
 
Messages
2,948
Reactions
2,180
Scales, of all varieties are very very sensitive to a number of things, beam scales must be kept clean, and free of dust, even the dust that settles in a day or two could put you off by a few tenths. Which sounds like a lot, however 1/10th of a grain is 1/70,000 of a pound. I like digital scales, but I always keep a balance around for when something seems off (even after zeroing) you should also be aware of stray air currents near your reloading bench as even a slight breeze can put your calibration off by up to several grains if you're not careful. Even moving the scale around on the bench can change the measurement, so when you're setting up to reload, put your scale down, zero it, and then don't move it until you're done, or rezero after movement. I'm hyper-anal about it, so I have a big 10x10"x1" chunk of steel that's surface ground I use to keep my scale on.
 
Messages
2,405
Reactions
555
I like digital scales, but I always keep a balance around for when something seems off (even after zeroing)
There's a big discussion of this topic on another Forum.

For some reason people seem to prefer another scale rather than just a simple set of check weights. As someone "over there" stated, "a man with two watches never knows which has the correct time".

Check weight sets are $30. A good beam scale usually runs twice that and upward.

The nice thing about check weights, like the RCBS set, one can create a check weight amount in increments of .5 gr all the way up to 65 grains.

I like to check my scale, even after calibrating and zeroing, with a weight as close as possible to my desired load. For example, my "accuracy" load for .308 is 43.5 grains. I place 2) 20gr. weights, 1) 2 gr., 1) 1gr., and 1) .5 gr weight on the pan and if it doesn't read exactly 43.5 grains we start over by cleaning, calibrating, etc. Just using another scale, unless it's a lab grade balance beam scale using individual reference weights (like we used to use in Science Class) all you are proving is that the scales don't agree. Which one is right????

Check Weights are the only accurate method without spending a small fortune for a lab grade scale that will still rely on check or reference weights.
 
Messages
2,405
Reactions
555
+1 re: check weights.

Digital Scales vary just as often as beam scales do; they are prone to a variety of interference.

Nate
My major gripe with beam scales is that they don't respond well to very small changes. Most consumer grade beam type scales tend to stick somewhat and in order to make sure they are registering that extra granule or two of powder you have to actually tap the pan to get the beam to swing. You then have to gauge whether the swing is equal above and below the center point or you have to wait until it stops moving. Either way it takes time. Time that a digital scale doesn't waste.
 

Spitpatch

Messages
2,494
Reactions
2,430
Where AMProd claims to be anal, I guess I'm "colon"-al. I use the digital scale mostly, but keep my fine OHAUS 304 Dial-Beam handy AND check weights. Too many times getting well into charging a batch of cases, and finding something a bit off, then trying to backtrack to find where the error began. Ditto on DeadShot's idea of a slab of surfaced countertop dedicated to scale placement. One other thing: I once had my scale placement near the edge of the bench. Scale kept fluctuating (this was the OHAUS 304). Took me most of a day to figure out the furnace vent was in that corner of the room: when the furnace would kick on, the air movement would dink with the scale. Texfisher, you can tell ME I'm an idiot.
 
Messages
5
Reactions
0
I am using my digital scale for my shop it's doing work very well according to my experience now the mostly people using digital scales for there businesses and I think digital scale is easy for use and make no problem in weighing if you keep if maintain properly.
<broken link removed>
 
Messages
116
Reactions
153
Texfisher33
The 10-10 scale has a magnetic damper system that may have attracted some metal shavings , Check this out and clean any shavings from the area where the damper
blade moves up and down. If any shavings are in there it will possibly cause error readings.

Good Shooting

Lindy
 
Messages
6,597
Reactions
19,151
And if you need to check it quickly, one CC of distilled water weighs one gram, or 15.43 grains.

If you happen to have a syringe that will measure 1cc, and some distilled water.
Or, to reduce the chance for error, measure out 10ccs of DW, and it should weigh 154.3 grains.
Don't use tap water. Dissolved solids have mass too.
 
Messages
147
Reactions
9
Another way for a quick check is to weiga dollar bill. One dollar bill weighs 1 gram. I balance a lot of engines and we always show our customers how much a gram weighs. Once in a great awhile you will find a dollar bill will weigh just a little under one gram, so weight more than one.
 
Messages
710
Reactions
613
My check weights were dirt cheap. I have a 55 grain and 130 grain bullet I use as check weights. Got to use the same bullet though cause they can vary in weight by a few fractions of a grain. I agree you need check weights to use as a base line. If your scale is off by .7 grains from day to day or use to use, something is big time wrong with it.

I've found cheap electronic scales drift way too much, so I stick with my RCBS balance beam. I am on the verge of buying a good digital scale though...getting harder to see with the balance beam.
 
Messages
2,405
Reactions
555
Another way for a quick check is to weiga dollar bill. One dollar bill weighs 1 gram. I balance a lot of engines and we always show our customers how much a gram weighs. Once in a great awhile you will find a dollar bill will weigh just a little under one gram, so weight more than one.
Would that be a "Reagan Era" dollar bill or an "Obama Buck"? Last I looked, an Obama Buck was a lot "lighter" at the cash register. Wouldn't buy near as much:cool:

Seriously, dollar bills make for poor weight standards. Can absorb all kinds of contaminants and if the edges wear off the weight can vary.

If one is concerned about accuracy of the scale then invest in the real tool, test weights. Anything else is just guessing and involves a lot of assumptions.
 
Messages
147
Reactions
9
Don't use the Obama Buck they will give you bad information. You are correct about the dollar, you need one that is pretty new and then they will very just a little, most of them will be the same. Like you said if you want very accuracy then you need to get some test weights.
 
Messages
3
Reactions
1
I actually found this site while using google to find information on the RCBS 10-10. So props to the OP I got some questions answered and I found what looks like a pretty cool site!
 

UPCOMING EVENTS

Arms Collectors of SW Washington Gun Show
Battleground Community Center
912 E Main St, Battle Ground, WA 98604, USA
DRRC .22 Rimfire Challenge Oct 10
Douglas Ridge Rifle Club
27787 OR-224, Eagle Creek, OR 97022, USA
Oregon State Steel Challenge Championship
Central Oregon Shooting Sports Association
Millican, OR 97701, USA
Miller's Quarry Clean-Up
Miller's Quarry
Miller Rd, Mt Hood Village, OR 97067, USA
Free Firearms Safety Course (I-1639 Compliant)
Virtual Webinar (Zoom)
Seattle, WA, USA

LATEST RESOURCE REVIEWS

  • Triple B Guns
    5.00 star(s)
    Triple B Guns
    This isn't really a review as we own the store but rather an invitation to come down and visit us. We specialize in hard to find unique guns but...
  • J&B Firearm Sales
    5.00 star(s)
    Good local shop
    Picked up a rifle yesterday from J&B. This was the second or third gun purchase over the last few years from them. I always enjoy stopping by...
  • H&K Gun Shop
    5.00 star(s)
    The only place I have found 9mm in stock
    I’ll admit I didn’t even know this place existed, as I don’t tend to go into Forest Grove often. But it’s a giant (looks bigger from the...
  • Revelation Arms
    4.00 star(s)
    Depends who answers the phone
    I was given the number to Roger Loock by Beaver Creek Armory, as I needed parts I had ordered from MCarbo installed on a Kel-Tec Sub2000. On my...
  • Coastal Farm & Ranch - Cornelius
    3.00 star(s)
    Lesson learned
    I’ll take some responsibility here, as I took the employee at their word instead of doing a thorough inspection. Short story is that I asked for a...
Top Bottom