Most Overrated Firearm

Discussion in 'General Firearm Discussion' started by raftman, May 12, 2019.

  1. raftman

    raftman
    Oregon
    Bronze Supporter Bronze Supporter

    Messages:
    1,433
    Likes Received:
    838
    I thought it was a fun topic. What is in y’alls opinion the most overrated firearm ever, and why?

    My answer... and it may be controversial but I’d go with the Stg-44. While the general idea of the assault rifle (select fire, intermediate cartridge) as it was applied was quite a game changer... the gun itself was actually pretty mediocre at best. The British and US military had mostly negative things to say about captured examples that were evaluated during WW2. In particular they knocked its weight and lack of durability. They were evidently so unimpressed, they would make pretty much no serious effort to adopt an assault rifle of their own, and would not for decades... by which point it was more in response to the success of the AK. I’ve also heard from modern day collectors that own them, that they are indeed fairly rickety and not very reliable. The Soviets did end up liking the idea of an assault rifle but (despite common misconceptions) didn’t copy the Stg-44 itself but worked out a design which borrowed elements from other successful designs and taking almost nothing directly from the actual Stg-44. So beyond it being an early, successful assault rifle there’s really no reason for it to enjoy the reputation that has.
     
    zenbreath and gaijinsamurai like this.
  2. AndyinEverson

    AndyinEverson
    Everson, Wa.
    Moderator with a Black powder affinity... Staff Member Silver Supporter

    Messages:
    10,551
    Likes Received:
    51,142
    The Glock series of pistols and the Ruger 10 /22 Series of rifles.
    "Over-hyped" might be a better term for my thoughts on these firearms, rather than overrated.


    With that said..both are excellent firearms.
    I think that they are over-hyped simply because...
    They are among the first firearms that come to mind when when people mention guns...
    ( Maybe along with a AR15 type rifle as well )
    They do indeed work well ...but to my eye , they also lack a lot in the looks department and just how they feel , to me is UGH at best.
    And many other firearms do work as well , yet have more visual appeal.
    ( At least to me...but in the big scheme of things , that don't matter much )

    And with that said...
    I stated my thoughts here , not to bash Glocks , Ruger 10/22's or AR15 rifles or their owners...
    As I said they work and work well.
    I just find them over-hyped , for what they are and what they do...Which really doesn't matter , as most folks find my taste in firearms not to their liking.

    If pressed for a overrated firearm..
    I'd say any modern inline muzzleloader...
    They don't shoot any better than an original or traditional style muzzleloader...yet according to salesmen , magazines , and the " wonderful " Toby Bridges...they are the best thing since sliced bread.
    Andy
     
    KKG, 3putts, orygun and 10 others like this.
  3. Cucv

    Cucv
    Happy Valley
    Bronze Supporter Bronze Supporter

    Messages:
    133
    Likes Received:
    189
    A battle ship
     
    dcfranzen likes this.
  4. dcfranzen

    dcfranzen
    New Bern, NC
    Bronze Supporter Bronze Supporter

    Messages:
    154
    Likes Received:
    284
    Walther PPK. It might be one of the most iconic pistols of the 20th century, but it is James Bond movie hype that has set it on a pedestal.
     
    Last edited: May 12, 2019
    gaijinsamurai, orygun, bbbass and 6 others like this.
  5. edslhead

    edslhead
    Vanc
    Gold Supporter Gold Supporter Silver Supporter

    Messages:
    3,578
    Likes Received:
    9,659
    Cabot Gentleman's carry. Because I cant afford one:(
     
    orygun and dcfranzen like this.
  6. jbett98

    jbett98
    NW Oregon
    Silver Supporter Silver Supporter 2018 Volunteer

    Messages:
    9,734
    Likes Received:
    16,944
    A semi auto Thompson. Now, a full auto Thompson is a different story.
     
  7. edslhead

    edslhead
    Vanc
    Gold Supporter Gold Supporter Silver Supporter

    Messages:
    3,578
    Likes Received:
    9,659
    Seriously , the 30/30 is way overrated for hunting in my opinion.
     
    Portaledgepete and nwwoodsman like this.
  8. ZA_Survivalist

    ZA_Survivalist
    There
    Bronze Supporter Bronze Supporter

    Messages:
    5,427
    Likes Received:
    7,805
    Not firearms but, Rmrs on pistols and 300 blackout.
     
    Basedgreaser and aksu747 like this.
  9. BrandonQuixote

    BrandonQuixote
    Cedar Hills
    Gold Supporter Gold Supporter

    Messages:
    101
    Likes Received:
    116
    The 1911 platform as a whole.

    dztto54441wy.png
     
  10. MechaNik

    MechaNik
    Western OR
    Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    292
    Likes Received:
    512
    Anything someone else has that I don't because that's how my opinions work
     
  11. gryghin

    gryghin
    Beaverton
    Gold Supporter Gold Supporter

    Messages:
    580
    Likes Received:
    513
    I find the 1911 overrated.

    I mean maybe if it was a firearm that was designed to kill savages that a 38 or 357 wouldn't stop.

    If it was a reliable design that would keep functioning regardless of years of poor depot maintenance.

    Wait, what does overrated mean? It does not mean what I think it means.
     
    pandog, zenbreath, farsidius and 5 others like this.
  12. aksu747

    aksu747
    Beaverton
    Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    635
    Likes Received:
    693
    Nah, 1911's are great.
    That said a lot of them are overpriced from the factory.
    I see more undeserved hate for the 1911's more than any other firearm except for maybe hi-points and taurus anything.
     
    orygun, SUPER X, Mr Smith and 3 others like this.
  13. BrandonQuixote

    BrandonQuixote
    Cedar Hills
    Gold Supporter Gold Supporter

    Messages:
    101
    Likes Received:
    116
    .357 Mag was developed almost 25 years after the 1911 platform was. I don't think it was competing with a caliber yet to be created.
     
  14. ZigZagZeke

    ZigZagZeke
    Eugene
    Curmudgeon Gold Supporter 2015 Volunteer

    Messages:
    4,289
    Likes Received:
    9,206
    It was competing with the .38 long Colt.
     
    Oohrah, Mr Smith, Ura-Ki and 2 others like this.
  15. BrandonQuixote

    BrandonQuixote
    Cedar Hills
    Gold Supporter Gold Supporter

    Messages:
    101
    Likes Received:
    116
    Yeah, But NOT .357 mag as the quote above stated, which is my point.
    Also black powder cartridge v.s smokeless isn't exactly a level playing field.
     
    Pandaz3, SUPER X and bbbass like this.
  16. AndyinEverson

    AndyinEverson
    Everson, Wa.
    Moderator with a Black powder affinity... Staff Member Silver Supporter

    Messages:
    10,551
    Likes Received:
    51,142
    .38 Long Colt is .357 in diameter , just sayin'
    Andy
     
    orygun, Mr Smith, Ura-Ki and 3 others like this.
  17. ZigZagZeke

    ZigZagZeke
    Eugene
    Curmudgeon Gold Supporter 2015 Volunteer

    Messages:
    4,289
    Likes Received:
    9,206
    Most over-rated is the Glock. In almost every endeavor, from skiing, to fly fishing, to hunting, to mountain climbing there is a common belief among those new to the sport that if they simply go out and buy whatever the "pro's" use they will immediately be experts. I see people in Maupin with $3000 fly rods and $1200 waders beating the water to a froth because they don't know how to fly fish. I see people on the ski slopes doing the "snow plow" while wearing $20K worth of equipment. It's no different with guns. That's not to say that nobody has any use for a Glock. Police and military probably need a pistol without extra features that might break and disable the weapon. They probably need a light weight polymer pistol if they carry one 24/7. But every novice thinks that a Glock is the ultimate weapon and wants one.
     
  18. BrandonQuixote

    BrandonQuixote
    Cedar Hills
    Gold Supporter Gold Supporter

    Messages:
    101
    Likes Received:
    116
    To quote my wife, "same diameter, different effect."
     
  19. BrandonQuixote

    BrandonQuixote
    Cedar Hills
    Gold Supporter Gold Supporter

    Messages:
    101
    Likes Received:
    116
    But hey, if y'all like real heavy handguns designed before we had a polio vaccine or penicillin with a single digit capacity in a caliber that has the same energy as a 115gr +P 9x19 and a propensity to refuse to run good defense ammo...
    Also, probably not a good sign when JMB's last project didn't chamber in .45 AARP.

    Also, the irony of my avatar pointing a GI model 1911 isn't lost on me.
     
    BroncoFan and MechaNik like this.
  20. AndyinEverson

    AndyinEverson
    Everson, Wa.
    Moderator with a Black powder affinity... Staff Member Silver Supporter

    Messages:
    10,551
    Likes Received:
    51,142
    Well to be honest ...
    I don't care what anyone likes in a firearm..as long as they are safe and proficient it its use.
    To be fair... I like the 1911..have had long experience with it and even carried it in combat...not used , but I did carry it and didn't feel undergunned ...'course at that time and place , I also carried and used a M21...:D

    If what you use works for you...then great...just don't be telling me that what works for me , is something that I need to change.
    ( Not that anyone here in this thread has said that...but I have been told this before. )
    Andy
     

Share This Page