JavaScript is disabled
Our website requires JavaScript to function properly. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser settings before proceeding.
Good idea but bad execution. The bill is unconstitutional because it makes it a crime for federal agents to enforce federal laws (Supremacy Clause) and infringes on the reporter's first amendment rights. It would just result in expensive legal fees when the state was sued for the law. They could have easily passed laws that would have been constitutional muster with a law preventing local authorities from assisting with federal gun law investigations and making it a crime for government officials to release information on CHL.

I know that the idea sounds great but we always complain about the other side passing unconstitutional laws and we should hold our side to the same standards.
 
Except that the Fed doesn't have any more authority than is specifically enumerated in the Constitution, anything else NOT enumerated is an individual State issue.

It's like saying, "the SCOTUS upheld the Arizona immigration bill against the DOJ challenge because coming into the country illegal is already illegal", in other words how can a State law banning unconstituional Federal actions be unconstitutional?
 
Except that the Fed doesn't have any more authority than is specifically enumerated in the Constitution, anything else NOT enumerated is an individual State issue.

It's like saying, "the SCOTUS upheld the Arizona immigration bill against the DOJ challenge because coming into the country illegal is already illegal", in other words how can a State law banning unconstituional Federal actions be unconstitutional?

That there is some more good thinking Stomper. I am enjoying reading your take on things.

Let's make the most salient point bold... Except that the Fed doesn't have any more authority than is specifically enumerated in the Constitution, anything else NOT enumerated is an individual State issue.

Folks, go and read the Constitution. If you're not up on it, you'll weep for how far this great document has been tossed from the governing bodies.

Weep for the future.... But don't let the tears blur your vision through the iron sights and scopes at an Appleseed meet. Project Appleseed Home
 

Upcoming Events

Centralia Gun Show
Centralia, WA
Klamath Falls gun show
Klamath Falls, OR
Oregon Arms Collectors April 2024 Gun Show
Portland, OR
Albany Gun Show
Albany, OR

New Resource Reviews

New Classified Ads

Back Top