Other State California's Mag Ban Ruled Unconstitutional

[titsonritz]

Has prohibition ever worked?

You mean for instance, at creating a black market, making a bunch of derelicts rich, and driving up violent crime? Yeah, works great.

 

[FireArm]

Stock up on mags, buy enough for your children's children they will thank you one day. Ammos in the same boat, stock up, have the stuff to reload, don't run low.
I used to say you only needed a good shotgun, good rifle, and a good pistol, but the way things are going its probably a good idea to have backups of each and a good battle rifle or two. Its time for politicians to take a break.

 

[WoodsPlinker]

For those that don't like to read

The Law Ep 28, Duncan v. Becerra (SD CA 2019)

 

[Ura-Ki]

This paragraph quoted out of the Recent Ruling is the Clincher for ALL under the 9th court, and needs to be used within the States against the Anti 2nd push!

Defense against ordinary criminals may be a leading purpose of the Second Amendment, but it is not the only purpose. "Today, self-protection is most important. In the future, the common defense may once again be most important. Constitutional rights stand through time holding fast through the ebb and flow of current controversy." The government may not respond to bad political ideas by censoring speech, nor respond to crime waves "with warrantless searches and unreasonable seizures. Neither can the government response to a few mad men with guns and ammunition be a law that turns millions of responsible, law-abiding people trying to protect themselves into criminals.

 

[1Asterisk]

At what point does the populace go from "I am doing the best I can to be a law abiding citizen" to "random acts of non-compliance" to " I WILL NOT COMPLY!" ?????????

If it is time to start burying them, then it is time to start shooting them.

 

[DivCurlGrad72]

Just saw that Duncan v. Becerra was heard yesterday in the 9th circuit. Need to follow up more myself, so I'll just leave this here for now:

You can watch the entire hearing here:

 

[cigars]

Now it goes to the 9th circus

Which is now majority conservative, thanks to Trump!

 

[DivCurlGrad72]

If this source is correct, the judges in this case are (appointing President):

Callahan(George W) is the lady with the glasses on the left, Lee(Trump) is the male judge on the right, Lynn(Clinton)

So a 2:1 decision?

 

[GWS]

If this source is correct, the judges in this case are (appointing President):

So a 2:1 decision?

Man, I hope you're right.

 

[ma96782]

Aloha, Mark

 

[po18guy]

Lest we forget recent Trump appointee Lawrence Van Dyke, to the 9th circuit: IDPA member, AR shooter and defender of the 2A.

National - Trump adds IDPA shooter to 9th Circuit Court of Appeals

Van Dyke. At the top of page 51 of his judiciary committee questionnaire he describes his IDPA membership. First IDPA member on a court of appeals?

www.northwestfirearms.com

 

[MrRob96]

Lest we forget recent Trump appointee Lawrence Van Dyke, to the 9th circuit: IDPA member, AR shooter and defender of the 2A.

National - Trump adds IDPA shooter to 9th Circuit Court of Appeals

Van Dyke. At the top of page 51 of his judiciary committee questionnaire he describes his IDPA membership. First IDPA member on a court of appeals?

www.northwestfirearms.com

Oh great.... Now the mags will need to comply with some measurement in commie units like millimeters and/or be required to fit in some sort of box to be constitutional.

 

[po18guy]

???

 

[arakboss]

Oh great.... Now the mags will need to comply with some measurement in commie units like millimeters and/or be required to fit in some sort of box to be constitutional.

I got it

 

[nammac]

???

IDPA requirements...

 

[MrRob96]

???

The joke works better if he was a USPSA competitor but tomato tomato.

 

[DivCurlGrad72]

Which is now majority conservative, thanks to Trump!

Not quite, but hopefully soon! The best info I could find shows Dems. hold a 3-seat majority with 16 Dem-appointed judges, vs. 13 Rep-appointees.

 

[ZigZagZeke]

Not quite, but hopefully soon! The best info I could find shows Dems. hold a 3-seat majority with 16 Dem-appointed judges, vs. 13 Rep-appointees.

It matters whether it's being heard by a three judge panel or the whole court. Looks like it's a 3 judge panel, and that panel is 2:1 Republican appointed (meaning hopefully conservative).

 

[DivCurlGrad72]

It matters whether it's being heard by a three judge panel or the whole court. Looks like it's a 3 judge panel, and that panel is 2:1 Republican appointed (meaning hopefully conservative).

OK, yes, just sounded to me like cigars was referring to the whole court. I also mentioned above the 2:1 ratio in our favor in the present case. Fingers crossed.

 

[ZigZagZeke]

OK, yes, just sounded to me like cigars was referring to the whole court. I also mentioned above the 2:1 ratio in our favor in the present case. Fingers crossed.

Most importantly, if they rule against the ban, what will they say about Benitez's reasoning. It matters when they get to the USSC.