National 5th District puts down Federal bump stock ban

[Member 5605]

All things legal.

It's how you use them that is illegal.

 

[bradsteen]

My question is... now what? Are they appealing the decision to the Supreme Court? If not, wondering when they will start producing bump stocks for sale again.

 

[Yarome]

My question is... now what? Are they appealing the decision to the Supreme Court? If not, wondering when they will start producing bump stocks for sale again.

No word yet, but sure hope they do and I would think it's likely(?) If it stays a 5th district only decision it doesn't do anything for anyone else and likely won't see them back on the market any time soon.

 

[Stomper]

View attachment 1341798

Answer:

I got a bump-stock at your mom's and your sister's house…. for $20 each.

 

[Yarome]

Answer:

I got a bump-stock at your mom's and your sister's house…. for $20 each.

They make you pay??

Interesting..........

 

[Stomper]

They make you pay??

Interesting..........

They only "like" me, they don't "love" me…. there's a difference.

 

[Knobgoblin]

Everybody pays . Being nice and listening to stupid gossip. Fixing cars. Getting stuff down from high shelves.
The currency used is the only difference.

Everyone pays

 

[FireArm]

When will the stocks be back on the shelves?

hehehehehe

tell me when I can start digging

 

[FireArm]

tell me when I can start digging

My question is... now what? Are they appealing the decision to the Supreme Court? If not, wondering when they will start producing bump stocks for sale again.

"they" probably wont be the same "they" that manufactured them previously, it would take some time to go back into production, Slide fire is long gone as a website and company.

 

[Yarome]

It looks like the bump stock case is headed to SCOTUS on petition from the DOJ. I guess they didn't like the idea of having to pay Cargill any remedy for his win in court so they asked the court to stay that portion of the judgement and are taking it directly to SCOTUS. Seeing how several disctrict courts are in conflict over bump stocks, it seems highly likely they will take it up.

https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.txwd.1016479/gov.uscourts.txwd.1016479.70.0.pdf

 

[The Heretic]

Fifth Circuit Finalizes Ruling In Favor of Plaintiff in Cargill v. Garland, Legalizes Bump Stocks in Three States - The Truth About Guns

&#9664Previous Post Next Post▶ Breaking News!!! 5th Circuit Court of Appeals issues mandate in Cargill v Garland, Bump Stocks are now legal in TEXAS, LOUISIANA & MISSISSIPPI. @ATFHQ did not request a stay. #2a #texas #txlege #pewpew #guncontrol #guns pic.twitter.com/076gGw5uCC — Michael Cargill...

www.thetruthaboutguns.com

Sorry if this is a duplicate.

 

[fmvolume86]

isn't this not in the best interest of the DOJ ??? or does the DOJ very confident they will win that they are pushign it to SCOTUS ? and hopefully just like Bruen this comes with a whole new list of SMACK DOWNS on the fascist Democrats

 

[Yarome]

isn't this not in the best interest of the DOJ ??? or does the DOJ very confident they will win that they are pushign it to SCOTUS ? and hopefully just like Bruen this comes with a whole new list of SMACK DOWNS on the fascist Democrats

Kinda sorta, sorta not.They are behind a rock and a hard spot. If they don't push it to SCOTUS and win, they are on the hook for a ton of remedy action for Cargill. I don't know what their confidence level is but it's the only option they have to potentially get off the hook.

For us I would say it's very good! Finally get this resolved... one way or the other... and have nationwide affect. To be aware though that "for" or "against" will have implications in some of the other pending cases... like braced pistols and the frames and receivers rules.

 

[Yarome]

The 3 Judge panel of the 6th Circuit court of appeals reversed the Hardin v. Alphabet district court ruling out of Kentuky. The bump stock rule is unconstitutional. Noice!!

https://www.opn.ca6.uscourts.gov/opinions.pdf/23a0086p-06.pdf

 

[ilikegunspdx]

The 3 Judge panel of the 6th Circuit court of appeals reversed the Hardin v. Alphabet district court ruling out of Kentuky. The bump stock rule is unconstitutional. Noice!!

https://www.opn.ca6.uscourts.gov/opinions.pdf/23a0086p-06.pdf

So currently the cargill case in the 10th is currently going to the Supreme Court I think (they haven't decided to take it yet)? And the 6th is saying bump stock are ok? Is that the bumpstock status so far in the us?

 

[Yarome]

So currently the cargill case in the 10th is currently going to the Supreme Court I think (they haven't decided to take it yet)? And the 6th is saying bump stock are ok? Is that the bumpstock status so far in the us?

Pretty much. We have 2 district courts upholding the alphabet's BS and now... 2 district courts saying, "back the bubblegum up". Making it more assured the case is going to require a SCOTUS ruling.

The parallels with the pistol brace rule are evident and will likely have further reaching implications.

 

[PiratePast40]

Pretty much. We have 2 district courts upholding the alphabet's BS and now... 2 district courts saying, "back the bubblegum up". Making it more assured the case is going to require a SCOTUS ruling.

The parallels with the pistol brace rule are evident and will likely have further reaching implications.

Is it time to get excited or is my banana dance premature?

 

[solv3nt]

Is it time to get excited or is my banana dance premature?

Put that thing away in public. Geez.

 

[Yarome]

Is it time to get excited or is my banana dance premature?

Yeah.... I'm not gonna touch that one....

What you do under your own roof is your business.

 

[solv3nt]

Yeah.... I'm not gonna touch that one....

What you do under your own roof is your business.

Just make sure you're under your roof within the walls (with the blinds closed) prior to busting out the banana dance