1911 recoil buffers, are they necessary?

[bwells]

I just ordered some new recoil springs for my 1911, and also ordered these recoil buffers to replace the old one in my gun:

http://www.midwayusa.com/viewProduct/?productNumber=740502

I'm just curious, how important are these to use? Do they really make a difference?

Read More

 

[jordanvraptor]

Only time I ever used them was in a Colt Combat Elite that I used to own. Adding the buffers led to malfunctions. Removed the buffers and all was well again. YMMV

 

[sheepman]

If they do not effect reliable operation then I use them. Some guns don't like them but others work OK. My 1911 is a range gun only, if it were a carry gun I would not use the buffer. They do work but can cause problems ( I believe they will help save frame battering). Short answer they are not necessary but may have a benefit for some guns. JMHO : Bill PS if you use one in a carry gun check it often for wear.

 

[huntpotter]

I use them in my Kimber pro carry. They help to keep down the frame battering., But also if you use +p ammo, you can up the recoil spring power by 2lbs, and that works well too. If they don't cause reliabilty problems, then why not use them. Old JM Browning didn't design it origionally, but that doesn't mean its a bad thing.

 

[Bello425]

+1 on Sheepman and Huntpotter. I used them and had no issues with them.

 

[wichaka]

I use them in every 1911 I own, except the sub 4 1/4" models. They take up room where the slide has to operate, so they can cause problems in shorter guns.

If you use them, just make sure you check over them like any other part of your gun when cleaning and/or doing maint. If you see cracks, throw it out and install a new one. And for carry use, make sure your gun will run with it. Some like 'em, some don't.