NY Judge says 2A doesn't exist there

[The Heretic]

NYC Man Convicted Over Gunsmithing Hobby After Judge Says 2nd Amendment 'Doesn't Exist in This Courtroom'

redstate.com

She told us, 'Do not bring the Second Amendment into this courtroom. It doesn't exist here. So you can't argue Second Amendment. This is New York.'

Read More

 

[Stomper]

Wow…. NY is well and try dead to me!

 

[Snip]

So all the other amendments are off the table too in NY? Slavery is legal now too? How about illegal search and seizure?

 

[Dozer99]

Well, it looks like NY State is right back where we started (1775).

 

[Mikej]

"New York". That's it, he's going to prison. And Donald Trump is being tried there.
What a crap hole as far as The Constitution goes.

 

[CamoDeafie]

That Judge should be disbarred with prejudice and jailed

 

[nammac]

That Judge should be disbarred with prejudice and jailed

Sure as he!! Should not be serving on the bench or dictating from the bench…. Wow, just wow!!! Guess there are no rights in NY…

I would expect crime to plummet in that "police state".

By the way folks, this is the result of decades of single party rule.

 

[Yarome]

I get the guy wasn't legally able to build an 80% in NY, but the judge went way beyond.

Could you imagine if a 1st amendment related case was going before a judge and a judge said, "Don't even bring it up. The 1st amendment doesn't exist in my courtroom."? It's just amazing how blatantly a sitting judge in a U.S. court, sworn to uphold the constitution, can flat our say the quiet part out loud in open defiance and in violation of her oath of office. How far we have fallen.

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JrizNJXQ0iw

 

[parallax]

How is she not disbarred?.. never mind..........................................................

 

[2ndtimer]

I get the guy wasn't legally able to build an 80% in NY, but the judge went way beyond. During opening remarks the defendants attorney mentioned the 2A and the judge immediately shut him down stating...

"Don't bring the second amendment into this courtroom. It doesn't exist here."

Could you imagine if a 1st amendment related case was going before a judge and a judge said, "Don't even bring it up. The 1st amendment doesn't exist in my courtroom."? It's just amazing how blatantly a sitting judge in a U.S. court, sworn to uphold the constitution, can flat our say the quiet part out loud in open defiance and in violation of her oath of office. How far we have fallen.

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JrizNJXQ0iw

Next to be eliminated will be the first and 4th amendments. Why should the Constitution of the United States of America apply? We are talking about the state of New York!

 

[Alexx1401]

A LOT of people have watched as the "justice system" has done this and supported it. As long as they were "going after" things or persons they did not like they think this is just grand. Most of them can not be reached when you try to warn them they are opening Pandora's Box here. So when they next find themselves the victim they will scream and of course it will be too late.

 

[Old Dog]

The fact that a sitting judge in a criminal trial anyone, never mind it's NY, feels comfortable stating that the 2A doesn't exist in her courtroom simply confirms the disdain, nay, the absolute contempt, that the liberals have for the 2A and the RKBA. And their confidence that they are above the law and that the Constitution is a useless relic.

We'll see if a mistrial occurs, or the defendant wins an appeal, or the judge is censured, impeached or removed -- but I highly doubt that will happen under the current administration.

 

[L84Cabo]

It is a MASSIVE shortcoming in our system, that a sitting judge could say this in open court...and there is ZERO means to IMMEDIATELY remove her from the bench for either gross incompetence or gross corruption. There's not even a long term means of removing her from the bench.

The irony here is that this type of tyranny is EXACTLY why our founder gave us the Second Amendment. What exactly are We The People supposed to do when our system fails this badly? What would our founders do?

 

[CamoDeafie]

NY Judge says 2A doesn't exist there

https://redstate.com/jeffc/2024/04/22/brooklyn-man-convicted-over-gun-hobby-by-biased-ny-court-could-be-facing-harsh-sentence-n2173162 She told us, 'Do not bring the Second Amendment into this courtroom. It doesn't exist here. So you can't argue Second Amendment. This is New York.'

www.northwestfirearms.com

Duplicate thread and yes. Its unfortunate that this Judge isn't disbarred and jailed along with the prosecutor team for conspiracy to deprive an American of his civil rights.

 

[TTSX]

Ok, well neither does the 14th, then

Yeah, not so funny is it?

 

[Xmark1]

It is a MASSIVE shortcoming in our system, that a sitting judge could say this in open court...and there is ZERO means to IMMEDIATELY remove her from the bench for either gross incompetence or gross corruption. There's not even a long term means of removing her from the bench.

The irony here is that this type of tyranny is EXACTLY why our founder gave us the Second Amendment. What exactly are We The People supposed to do when our system fails this badly? What would our founders do?

My immediate response would be to apply my tin-foil hat and ask for a change of venue.

 

[L84Cabo]

My immediate response would be to apply my tin-foil hat and ask for a change of venue.

That would likely be denied. Your attorney should then immediately ask the judge to declare a mistrial. But she's corrupt as hell so that would have been denied too. You're running out of options real quick. Looks like you'll be spending several nights in Rikers while your attorney appeals. Maybe several years. Of course, you will probably have a hell of a lawsuit if you ever get out. Maybe. I mea, if there are no provisions for dealing with a corrupt judge like this, you probably can't sue for it either.

 

[TTSX]

That would likely be denied. Your attorney should then immediately ask the judge to declare a mistrial. But she's corrupt as hell so that would have been denied too. You're running out of options real quick. Looks like you'll be spending several nights in Rikers while your attorney appeals. Maybe several years. Of course, you will probably have a hell of a lawsuit if you ever get out. Maybe. I mea, if there are no provisions for dealing with a corrupt judge like this, you probably can't sue for it either.

This is an option

View: https://youtu.be/7HV3O3t9hbQ?si=V2X-sx7TPBUhTTml

 

[IndyPrepper]

It is a MASSIVE shortcoming in our system, that a sitting judge could say this in open court...and there is ZERO means to IMMEDIATELY remove her from the bench for either gross incompetence or gross corruption. There's not even a long term means of removing her from the bench.

The irony here is that this type of tyranny is EXACTLY why our founder gave us the Second Amendment. What exactly are We The People supposed to do when our system fails this badly? What would our founders do?

Ya know..a sitting judge says this kind of crap and people wonder why 1/2 the country is ready to go full ape combat. I wonder what the movie Civil War's box office take is by now.

 

[L84Cabo]

Ya know..a sitting judge says this kind of crap and people wonder why 1/2 the country is ready to go full ape combat. I wonder what the movie Civil War's box office take is by now.

Our founders would be shooting people by now.

I also heard the Civil War movie was stupid. Maybe folks here have seen it and can comment.