Thread: Which handgun?

In a situation where you knew there would be tactical engagements (riots, looting, the commies invade, chaos in the streets) What would be your sidearm of choice (of the options listed):

Glock 19 (9mm 14+1)
Fullsize HK USP (.45acp 12+1)
Springfield Milspec 1911 (.45acp 7+1)

I'm throwing together a grab bag in case S really hits the fan. Trying to decide what mags and holster to attach.

What are your thoughts?

It would probably be a 1911, but since I am not a really big fan of the Springfield's, I vote for the good old standby Glock 19...

1911 all the way!

Fullsize USP.

Even though I am not a fan I had to vote for the 1911 due to the sheer number out there.

Hm, from that list, I like 1911 the best. But I'd get Colt or something, not Springfield cuz I'm just like that. List needs more DA/SA steel frame wonder 9s though. Where's the sig p226 or cz-75?

Originally Posted by spengo

Hm, from that list, I like 1911 the best. But I'd get Colt or something, not Springfield cuz I'm just like that. List needs more DA/SA steel frame wonder 9s though. Where's the sig p226 or cz-75?

list is composed of what I have available. my DA/SA wondernine is a Sig P6, but the limited mag capacity ruled that one out. for the same reason my revolvers or micro compacts are not listed.

First the price of HK is very expensive, save that money for 9mm ammos. I carry 45 cals daily just because I can afford 45 cals for target shooting to keep my personal defend. When SHTF 45 cal will be way too expensive to buy...... I will buy a glock 9mm and bunch of ammos save for SHTF.

9mm is the only real choice
the ammo is alot more common
15+ rounds would be best

id rather shoot myself in the foot then pick glock so i refuse to take your poll

Glock hands down. It has a higher capacity, is more than well-known for reliability, lightweight, durable, runs dirty as if it were born in a pigpen and, a big issue in 'shtf' stuff, the polymer frame wont rust

At the end of the day though, whatever you shoot best with and conceals well. You'll probably never use it anyways.

Glock. I have a G-17 and thats what in my grab bag

G19. It's the first gun I ever bought and still have it.




Will

Really, for me, it would be between the glock and the HK. 45 + high cap + full size = win. since CCW probably wouldn't be too much of an issue the extra sight radius is nice. But the out of the 3 the Glock would be the lightest and have the highest ammo to weight ratio. Also, with the glock you can run g17 mags and pick up a few extra rounds if you are really concerned about capacity. Is what it comes down to is which gun you feel most comfortable with and can shoot the best. I would rule out the 1911 just because of the weight and lack of capacity. Still a great side arm, but when it comes down to it, mag changes can slow you down at the worst times possible.

Already have a Springfield V10 packed in my "Oh Crap" bag...

IMO the Glock is the gun to bet your life on when SHTF

Glock? More capacity is necessary if you plan to miss a lot. If the 1911 has a good trigger and you know how to shoot it, that would be my choice. I have one of the first Kimbers made and it shoots excellent. I would recommend shooting star mags holds 8 rounds full size or 10 rounds extended.

Whatever is most familiar to you. I shoot 1911s, I would pick the Springfield because I am most oriented to that weapon system and if I can grab one of my nicer pistols all of the gear in the bag would be compatible.

Glock...more rounds, less moving parts, easier maintanence, ect.

own any of them, nor have I shot any of them. Guess it's up to you!!

Deen
NRA Benefactor/Recruiter
WAC Member
SWWAC Member

DW1911sFTMFW!